Explore

Communities in English

Advertise on Engormix

Use of Plant Extracts Rich in Tannic Acid and Polyphenols as Enhancing Agents of Poultry Intestinal Quality

Published: June 8, 2016
Summary
Several broiler producing countries have banned the use of Antibiotic Growth Promoters (AGPs) related to the risk of cross-resistance development in human pathogens. Removal of AGPs from animal diets involves tremendous pressure on poultry farmers. One of the main consequences is a substantial increase in the incidences of infectious diseases, with an associated rise in antibiotic use for therap...
Related topics:
Authors:
João Batista Lancini
Lavenco Consultoria e Representações Ltda.
Nicola Panciroli
Silvateam
Influencers who recommended :
Marcelo Paolella
Recommend
Comment
Share
Dr Abdulla Ahmad tahir
9 de junio de 2016
Is there any effect of polyphenolic extracts like phenu greek, black cumin seed and black tea extracts and their oils on performance of layer and healh of layer. will u gie refrences
Recommend
Reply
João Batista Lancini
Lavenco Consultoria e Representações Ltda.
9 de junio de 2016

Dear Dr Abdulla Ahmad Tahir, thanks for your request. Actually, the product related in the publication is ENC or Nutri P (commercial name in Brazil). This product is based, basically, on two plant extracts: Quebracho and Chestnut both with high tannin and polyphenols concentration - . Tannins are wide in all plants but the diference is related to the hability to extract them from the plant and the caracteristics of each coumpound (condensed tannins like procyanidinics or hydrolizable like galotannin, etc). So, all plants you related have some tannins concentration, mainly black tea, that have much more data on it, but unfortunatelly I don`t have specific information about these plants. If you want more details about Nutri P or ENC effect on layer performance and intestinal health, I will be glad to send you by email. Please, contact us here. Best regards! Lancini

Recommend
Reply
Dr. E. Balamurugan
Himalaya
9 de junio de 2016
Tannins also has anti nutritional factors. How it is managed for improving the performance.
Recommend
Reply
Dr Kibiike David
10 de junio de 2016
Please help me to understand how exactly these tannic extract could work, to improve on the intestinal performance. Do they do that by improving on the on intestinal lining or by anti bacterial effect.
Recommend
Reply
Sushil Chandra
10 de junio de 2016
De-taninfication in commercial scale is costly process.Even after that it has to seen the effect on performance of laying birds at different level of dosages
Recommend
Reply
RAMA PRASAD CHAKRABORTY
10 de junio de 2016
It becomes beyond my convincing capacity to note that Tannic acid has a positive impact on nutritional ground as the component has always been recognized to be the anti -nutritional since beginning .Please give details of the pharmodynamics of same to improve intestinal function.
Recommend
Reply
RAMA PRASAD CHAKRABORTY
10 de junio de 2016
My qestion is that how could anyone proclaim TANIC ACID in feed or any polyphenol is benificial to poultry intentine?
Recommend
Reply
João Batista Lancini
Lavenco Consultoria e Representações Ltda.
10 de junio de 2016

Dear All, Dr. Balamurugan, Dr.David, Dr. Chandra, Dr. Chakraborty, Dr. Ponebsek.

Thanks for your questions and inputs. I`m not a nutritionist or a veterinarian specialized in pharmacology or toxicology. May background is on poultry intestinal health.

Besides all scientific papers, the best way to be sure about the tannins action is using them, facing intestinal disorders in the field. My experience was very positive on that, using big customers as reference.

Bellow I would like to share my opinion and SilvaTeam informations about your questions. I`m glad to share it with you and hope we can learn more about this new and very exciting assumption. Now a day, there are hundreds publications about it on internet.

“My qestion is that how could anyone proclaim TANIC ACID in feed or any polyphenol is benificial to poultry intentine?”


The answer could be: none!
1) Tannic acid is a defined molecule, thus much more easy to define it´s activity. NutriP is rich in Tannic acid, but also other components derivated from its extraction, as castalgine and other components present in the raw material from which we make the extraction.
2) Polyphenol is a huge family of molecules, include lignin, and many other components without bacteriostatic or antibacterial activity. Similar should be talking about Vitamins and expect all of them to have antioxidant properties.
Once one give precision to a definition, then effects and activities could be more clarified.


Toshitsugu et al at the Biological Pharmaceutical Bulletin. 27 (12) 2004 said: “Recently, many biochemical and epidemiologic studies have revealed that polyphenols of various foods and herbs are beneficial to human health, and some extracts of polyphenols-rich plants, such as green tea and grape seed, have been applied to functional foods or supplements. The potent biological activities of green tea polyphenols in, for example, cancer and cardiovascular disease prevention (Mukhtar H., Ahmad N., 2000), have been attracting scientists in medicinal and pharmaceutical fields. Tea polyphenols were also shown to have antibacterial (Hara Y., Ishigami T, 1989; Toda M. 1989, Toda M. Okubo S., Ikigai H., Shimamura T., 1990), antiviral (Nakayama M., et al, 1993) and antifungical activities (Okubo S., Toda M., Hara Y., Shimamura T., 1993) in addition to their inhibitory effects on exotoxins (Ikigai H. et al 1993).
Johnson, B.J. et al, 2008 cited the proanthocinidins capacity to bind LPS (lipopolysacarides) like that find in Clostridium perfringens exotoxins.
Dr. Mariano Myakawa et al. 2016 presented the potencial of Chestnut and Quebracho extracts to inhibit in vitro alpha and epsilon toxin activity at relatively low tannin concentration.
In the past there was very few studies about the polyphenols effect on animal production. Today, there are lots of scientific studies showing different activities. The main point to consider is that under the general therm “tannins” concept there are hundreds of different substances with different characteristics. Each one, depending on different factors like: plant, active compound, extraction method, etc, can act as an anti-nutritional factor or as a benefit product to animals. These types of polyphenols, such as hydrolysable and condensed tannins, are widely distributed in the plant kingdom and have the potential to be functional material.

Among the mechanism of action described until know:
1. Regulating the intestinal microbiota (Chen, Y.2012)
2. Reducing the immunological stress (antioxidant effect - Gulcin et al., 2010; Makino et al., 2011; Cai et al, 2005; Yilmaz et al., 2004; Leopoldini et al., 2011; Andrade et al., 2005, Tarabra, E. and Hernández, E. 2010)
3. Antispasmodic effect (Budriesi, et al, 2010)
4. Bacterial inhibition (Salmonella typhimurium – Costabile,A. et al, 2011, Massi, P. et al,2007 ; Clostridium perfringens – Elizondo, A.M. et al, 2010)
5. Toxin inhibition (Elizondo, A.M. et al, 2010)
6. Antiviral activity (Lupini, C. et al. 2006)


“ Please help me to understand how exactly these tannic extract could work, to improve on the intestinal performance. Do they do that by improving on the on intestinal lining or by anti bacterial effect.”
The tannic acids we refer to improve intestinal performance through different mode of actions, not just only one. They do act regulating the peristalsis in the intestinal tract, avoiding fast transit problems (Budriesi, et al, 2010; Micucci, M. et al, 2014) as well as their effect on different pathogens in the intestine, increasing general feed digestion conditions (Biagi, G. et al, 2010) related to "Effect of tannins on growth performance and intestinal ecosystem in weaned piglets". Other files regarding this effect are available on request. The other factor is the antioxidant effect, avoiding certain pathogens growth, together with the quelation of certain metals essential for pathogens growth.( Gulcin et al., 2010; Makino et al., 2011; Cai et al, 2005; Yilmaz et al., 2004; Leopoldini et al., 2011; Andrade et al., 2005, Tarabra, E. and Hernández, E. 2010)

“Tannins also has anti nutritional factors. How it is managed for improving the performance.”

That is also true, and depending on the type of tannin (condensed or hydrolysable) and its concentration, adverse effects could be observed. Negative effects are related to protein digestion and complete feed digestibility. No negative effect have been observed for the tannins we combine for NutriP either ByPro, enven at dosages 10 times higher than the recommended ones where dosages up to 5% of chestnut extract concentration in the feed do not generate adverse effects (Hervás, G. et al, 2003. Nutri P is recommended to poultry feed at the dosage of 0,5 to 1,0 kg/metric ton and there are not observed any impact on feed consumption or anti nutritional effect, just the opposite.


“De-taninfication in commercial scale is costly process.Even after that it has to seen the effect on performance of laying birds at different level of dosages”
Nutri P/ENC can be considered a helping hand in layer hen production, considering liability and the egg laying rate, by improving the digestion and absortion of nutrients (Reddy, K and Pradeep, K. 2012).
Yes, depending on the typpe of tannin, as said, adverse effects could be observed, mainly in protein digestion. Tannin components are like fruits: very different between themselves, even when all are from the same family. But bananas could not be compared with apples. On the other side, it is not the same to talk about native tannins than comparing them with added tannins. A full analysis of tannins´digestion is being analyzed by one of the teams with more knowledge on tannins in the world (Hagerman, A. et al., 1992).

“ It becomes beyond my convincing capacity to note that Tannic acid has a positive impact on nutritional ground as the component has always been recognized to be the anti -nutritional since beginning .Please give details of the pharmodynamics of same to improve intestinal function.”
Since the beginning (about 2500 million years before), tannins were develloped by plants to protect themselves and hervibores co-evoluted with them, develloping a metabolical system to take profit of these substances. Ancienne gallenic medicine, as well as many Oriental cultures use vegetable extracts to treat illnesses and also solve intestinal disorders and patogenic problems. When intensification of livestock happened, nutricionists focus their requirement on key factors as proteins, fats, carbohydrates, excluding minor components that were natural ingredients in animals diet. Tannins become negative due to their interaction with proteins and the concept of protein digestibility reduction, as said in the point above. Further research, starting on the 2000 shows mainly positive effect of tannins, in several aspects, as antibacterial, antioxidant, etc.
Considering different types of tannins, condensed ones have the possibility to bind selective different types of proteins, being in this way bacteriostatic elements, and afterwards excreted (recovered in the feces) while hydrolysable tannins are metabolized and derivate in gallic acid/ellagic acid (potent antioxidants), plus sugar.(Garcia-Muñoz; Vaillant, F.,2014)


“Aren´t Quebracho tannins antinutritional. In chemical structure are similar like tannins found in sorghum or in rape seed? We were taught that such tannins are antinutritional?”

As showed in the references above, quebracho tannin antinutritional effect depends on the dosage, as most of the components you can include in a diet, in this case, with much more wider safety range. Rusdi (2004) shows that 5% quebracho tannin content in a feed formula can cause intake depression, what is 50 times higher than the usual recommended usage. Other references are available on demand.

Recommend
Reply
Dr. Rama Prasad Chakraborty
11 de junio de 2016
The entire write up goes bit debatable.Nevertheless the component like tannic acid or any polyphenol item like lignin are at all advocable to become a part of any ingredients because they inhibit the nutrient availability to the livestocks.May be their presence now cause the restriction in nutrient utilization during the process of digestion to any POULTRY and thus giving some space to the process for ensuring protection to the intestine which is exposed to the affluent of nutrients through feeds by the owner of the firm.Hence resorting to the effect through Tannic Acid incorporation rather than imposing restriction in feeding regime may yield similar shield to the intestine.A TRIAL REPORT on same showing control group without NUTRI-P and experimental group with the component under discussion would certainly open the lid of the entire argument.Hence dispense same in comparative manner. Dr.R.P.Chakraborty,Ranchi,INDIA,
Recommend
Reply
Dr Kotaiah Talapaneni
Indbro Research & Breeding Farms
Indbro Research & Breeding Farms
11 de junio de 2016
With the restriction/ ban on use of antibiotics and aggressive welfare issues are changing the way the birds are fed and managed. Plant materials have been traditionally proven. Some people want to take the opportunity to market them fast. We should explain a basis of it, use. Prove how it works conduct a trial. Repeat it in larger scale. Then it can be sold. Some body found a literature that a particular leaf is rich in methionine. Yes. True. It has 2% more of methionine. Some body shows that literature and wants to sell it as a substitute to dl methionine which has 99% activity.
Recommend
Reply
Dr. Rama Prasad Chakraborty
12 de junio de 2016
Dr.Kotaiah .It would be appreciable to know your comment on incorporation of TANNIC ACID or Any Polyphenol in poultry diet and to note their positive impact.You had virtually diverted the point of discussion towards utilization of antibiotic as growth promoter to poultry feed and their aftermath to the consumer of poultry meat.Please focus back yourselve to the crux of discussion instead.
Recommend
Reply
Dr Kotaiah Talapaneni
Indbro Research & Breeding Farms
Indbro Research & Breeding Farms
12 de junio de 2016
Tannins are bad for poultry and monogastric animals. Lot of literature is available. Tannins are the reason why sorgham is not preffered over corn. Should it be reinvented and glorified as an useful ingredient in the name of gut health. Tannins affect the production efficiency. Poly phenols have some anti oxidental properties. We need not feed plants to get antioxidental benefits. we have better ways.
Recommend
Reply
RAMA PRASAD CHAKRABORTY
12 de junio de 2016
Excellent that what I reiterated since brginning .Now every firmers should count on same.
Recommend
Reply
Shakil Hamid
12 de junio de 2016
What are risk with un-drawn dressed poultry?
Recommend
Reply
RAMA PRASAD CHAKRABORTY
13 de junio de 2016
If any one ask what risk holds to handle with undrawn Fish or Meat?Better ask some meaning full question instead to obtain forums opinion.
Recommend
Reply
christopher. J
Vipla nutricare
13 de junio de 2016
we have given hydrolysable tannins for cow & dogs also, we have seen little improvement in fat/ SNF improvement in milk & in dog little growth & litter quality has been improved. actually the dosage is the constraint here. more the dosage may upset the health of the animal. more trials to be made for the same.
Recommend
Reply
RAMA PRASAD CHAKRABORTY
13 de junio de 2016
Hydrolysable TANNIN would finally be metabolized to yield readily available energy.I do appreciate your view to conduct more trials on same.There are enough options to explore some other conventional and cheaper sources of energy rather than tasking us to get TANNED with UNCONVENTIONAL TANNIC ACID in poultry feed.
Recommend
Reply
christopher. J
Vipla nutricare
13 de junio de 2016
the main function is that it binds proteins/AA in the intestine even if you touch it mixed with water,it binds skin proteins/AA. similar effect in Vivo conditions.
Recommend
Reply
RAMA PRASAD CHAKRABORTY
13 de junio de 2016
Dr.Christopher .J- Your clarification seems to be hardly acceptable to many ends. The component TANNIC ACID is stated to bind with protein resulting same to be less bio-available until the protein molecule gets free from such entanglements , vis a vis your statement that it binds with the intestinal AA making them available to the host at a low key.Then how come the molecule TANNIN or poly-phenols become advantageous to any livestock ? To substantiate your claim please forward the trial report as discussed earlier.
Recommend
Reply
João Batista Lancini
Lavenco Consultoria e Representações Ltda.
13 de junio de 2016

Dear Dr, Chakraborty, thanks to share your experience with tannic acid in livestocks.
My experience, as I shared with your, is in the field.
In my concept, there is a big difference to talk about sorghum tannins or the other plants tannins, related to extracted polyphenols from plants extracts. It is necessary a industrial process to get different compounds. There are hundreds or thousands compounds classified under the umbrella "Tannin".
The sorghum experience, we all know, with its high concentration in condensed tannin is a old concept that everybody learn in the university and became for a long time as a negative pattern in therms of poultry results.
Otherwise, the polyphenols extract from the other group of compounds will depende on: 1. Plant specie, 2. Geografic region, 3. Active compound, 4. Plant age, 5. Extraction methodology, 6. dosage, etc.
In the case of Nutri P/SilvaTeam, there are based on hydrolyzable tannins (ellagitaninn, gallotannin, etc), not just condensed tannins (procyanidinic or profisetinidin) like you sorghum, quebracho, etc. Your comment, I hope, is under your experience with condensed tannins.
Hydrolysable tannins are hydrolysed by acids or bases to produce carbohydrate or phenolic acids, like digallic acid or gallic acid, for example.
Condensed tannins like proanthocyanidins are polymeric flavonoids with a more complex heterocyclic ring system, and have a strong protein bind capacity, as you cited.
Your inputs are completely right over the condensed tannins concept.
My experience is that under field challenge conditions in big companies, with the same nutriotional formulation and comparing the results in a, for example, 3 million bird/month, the intestinal integrity was much better, based on necropsy standards (0-3 scores) with lots of flocks with 10% or 14% better performance results, than the flocks without the NutriP/Silvafeed.
Otherwise, the foot pad lesions reduced more than 10% due the better excreta consistency and, consequentelly, much better litter conditions.
Again, it was my field experience. My experience with some trials in University`s experimental facilities, the results were not so good, due the lack of callenge. Like we can observe in lots of scientifc papers about growh promoters, probiotics, etc (50% positive, 50% negative in experimental conditions).
I agree with Dr. Christopher. We need to check. There are lots of opinions, all valids, but each situation is different when we talk about animal production.
Could you please share with us, your practical experiences with tannins? It was just with sorghum or any other compounds too?
Thanks again to enrich this forum. Very instructive.

Recommend
Reply
12
Profile picture
Would you like to discuss another topic? Create a new post to engage with experts in the community.
Featured users in Poultry Industry
Vivek Kuttappan
Vivek Kuttappan
Cargill
Research Scientist
United States
Shivaram Rao
Shivaram Rao
Pilgrim´s
PhD Director Principal de Nutrición y Servicios Técnicos de Pilgrim’s Pride Corporation
United States
Thu Dinh
Thu Dinh
Tyson
Tyson
United States
Join Engormix and be part of the largest agribusiness social network in the world.