Herbal methionine in broilers - Woo Kyun Kim

remove_red_eye 1156 forum 35 bar_chart Statistics share
Share :
close
Video information
See more
Miguel A Pérez Miguel A Pérez
Gerente de Comercio Exterior
September 20, 2018

Hi All,

I know that my comment can create controversy and rejection but in my humble opinion a protein replacer is always better than DL-Met or Herbal Met.

Thoughts?

Reply
Hamid Ibrahim Ismail Hamid Ibrahim Ismail
PhD Poultry nutrition
March 3, 2019

Thank you Dr. Kyun Kim for this focal point on the utilization of herbal methionine and other herbs product as a replacer of synthetic products eg synthetic DL. Methionine in poultry nutrition
here, I gladly like to share information with others; I and workers at Animal Production Research Centre (Kuku) carried out two different experiment on the year 1914. At that time the price of DL-Methionine became very high for poultry farmers in Sudan and they look for a cheaper source. We bought this product and did our reaches, later we got the information from where it comes.
This herbal methionine called (Phytonin) was imported by a Sudanese Co. (Almaha limited Co.) from Indian company (Natural Remedies).
Information about its effect on broiler or layer performance you can obtained it from the following published articles.


Ibrahim I. Hamid (2014) Investigations into the addition of herbal methionine (Phytonin) as a substitute of synthetic methionine in poultry feeds. 1-Effect of herbal methionine (Phytonin) Supplementation on performance and egg quality of laying hens. International Journal of Poultry Science. 13 (8): 480-483 .http://www.pjbs.org/ijps/ijps.htm.
Ibrahim I. Hamid (2014) Investigations into the addition of herbal methionine (Phytonin) as a substitute of synthetic methionine in poultry feeds. 2-Effect of herbal methionine (Phytonin) Supplementation on performance and carcass characteristics of broiler chicks. International Journal of Poultry Science, 13 (8): 484-488.http://www.pjbs. org/ijps/ijps.htm

Reply
Alagbe olujimi John Alagbe olujimi John
Animal Production & Health
March 4, 2019
Excellent work
Reply
March 3, 2019
Very interesting. I want to know more information about this topic.
Can you send me any links?
Reply
March 4, 2019
Equally interested,plz give details of herbal dl-methionine,composition/dose in broiler feed etc ar sardar
Reply
Dr. Md. Robiul Islam (dvm) Dr. Md. Robiul Islam (dvm)
Business Development Manager
March 4, 2019
How about Meth + of Liptosa , Spain ?
Reply
March 4, 2019
I really surprised about how do Herbal methionine can replace DL-Met by 50%.

We analyzed herbal methionine and there was no methionine at all.

We did dose response trial on herbal methionine and even no 0.00001% improvement in broiler performance.

Please be concise and scientific as possible. The only way to evaluate your product is ( dose response trial compared to DL-Met supplementation). and you will find really Zero response.

You may search for the health benefits of your (Herbal Product) rather than growth performance as other herbal supplementation do.

Please accept my comment and if you have any scientific evidence please share it for discussion.
Reply
March 10, 2019
Shady A. Khalil , I do highly agree with you. Thanks
Reply
March 4, 2019

We have published research on herbal met the correct way with dose-response and found no met activity.

Reply
Youssef Attia Youssef Attia
Professor
March 5, 2019
It us very useful in organic farming
Reply
March 5, 2019

Youssef Attia doesn’t help if it doesn’t work. DL-methionine allowed in organic production in USA.

Reply
Youssef Attia Youssef Attia
Professor
March 5, 2019
Results are contradictory from different big nutritional labs in the States. One big boss say something different, then more research are needed.
Reply
Rahat Mobeen Rahat Mobeen
M.Phil Animal Nutrition
June 8, 2019
Which product is better?
Liquid HMTBA
DL Meth
L Meth
Herbal meth .

I think HMTBA & L meth are better than others.
Reply
Would you like to discuss about this topic: Herbal methionine in broilers - Woo Kyun Kim?
Engormix reserves the right to delete and/or modify comments. See more details
Post a comment
 
   | 
Copyright © 1999-2019 Engormix - All Rights Reserved