Flamenbaum: "Only a very small amount of countries manage to cool cows off"

Published on:
Author/s :
483 15 Statistics
Share :
Q: What are the main consequences of heat stress?
A: Regarding milk production, there are different factors, not just volume, but also fat content and protein in the milk and quality of the milk; that means, the somatic cell count that increases when the cow is in that condition of stress.
It also affects fertility, and the effect is an increase of the days open above what is recommended or planned. This happens for two principal reasons. First, heat stress reduces the manifestation of "heat" in the cows and inseminations are lost in those less detected having heat stress during artificial insemination. Second, it lowers the conception rate and both factors, together, extend the calving interval above the optimal level.
Q: What are the main signs of heat stress?
A: There are several. The cow eats less, drinks more water, is less active and searches humid places to try to cool off. The struggle with heat stress can be noticed in an increase of the breathing rhythm and panting as mechanisms to dissipate heat.
Normally, a high-producing cow can't dissipate on its own the heat it generates, therefore body heat rises and that is one of the parameters we use. When it rises, we know the cow is suffering heat stress and the damages begin: decrease in milk production, which is caused mainly by lower food intake of the cow, then also fat content, protein, etc. The cow ruminates less, it tends to stand still to lose heat, it doesn't rest, and when the cow has to be inseminated, it doesn't get pregnant.
Q: What advice can you give for prevention and treatment?
A: First of all, most of our work is preventive. We try to give the best conditions to the cow. Enough shade, sufficient space per cow, we look for facilities to be well aired, with natural ventilation. We give them enough space in the drinkers and fresh food during the day.
We do all this to avoid heat stress, but everything I mentioned can't prevent heat stress when the weather is too hot. The reason is the cow generates great heat, 900 watts for maintenance plus 100 watts per every 4,5 liters that it produces. A cow that produces 45 liters of milk then generates 1.900 watts.
That is why the cow has no chance of dissipate that heat, being a high producer because it is not something that nature has designed it for. It can't dissipate all the heat it generates in hot weather conditions. If we don't do anything, the cow slow downs its metabolism, lowers its food intake, and it will fall to the level of production that allows to dissipate the generated heat, which is around 10 liters of milk, but that it is not what we expect the cow to produce.
If we want high levels of milk production that correspond to that of the genetic potential of a Holstein cow, for example, that is about 50 liters a day, we have to cool off the cow, provide food, water and shade, and we do that through cooling systems that help the cow lose a lot of heat.
Regarding cooling systems, there are two basic ones. The first, that we call direct cooling, uses fans, cloth, and more than anything the combination of baths with forced ventilation. The other, indirect cooling, is more used in dry climates with vaporized water drops inside enclosed facilities, and the water evaporation lowers the temperature inside the place. These are systems for desertic zones but do not work as efficiently in humid zones. Most of the projects that I work on are in relatively humid zones, so the direct cooling system is the one that I use the most in my work.
Q: What are the conditions to apply direct cooling and how much of it is automatic?
A: The cow generates heat all day, so treatment has to be continuous, every day. It has to be frequent so the body temperature of the cow lowers to normal and it stays fresh.
The combination of water and ventilation is automatic, it works with timers, but the human part is to take the cows to the treatment, a number of times during the day, and for that there is no automatization, we do it with hired personnel.
In differents barns, and this is part of the profession, you have to decide what type of cooling locations to use and in what conditions, but regularly we have three main locations to cool them off.
One is the holding pen, where the cows are gathered to be milked, and we use it to cool them off. Sometimes it is not enough the time that we give them for it in this location, because of how fast the milking process is, so to extend cooling time we build special tunnels in the entrance and the exit.
If we milk the cow three times a day, it means that we cool it off every 8 hours, but a high-producing cow requires to be cooled off every 4 hours. To be able to do this, then we have to give them treatment between each milking, which can be done in tunnels between pens, to minimize the distance the cow would have to move, or in the feed stalls, and then you can cool them off while they're eating. The decision of where and how to do it is taken in each production unit according to the specific conditions of it.
Q: You have researched Summer to Winter ratio. ¿What would be a good ratio?
A: I take the hotest three months of the year and the coldest three ones to do it, taking into account the average production of the cow for those periods. In successful barns, that ratio is up to 95, 96 even 98 per cent. In the barns that are failing or not cooling enough the cows, the ratio can go down to 80 per cent in the summer. Extreme cases have shown 70 per cent, so the loss goes up to 30 there. And I have also gone to very, very hot places in the world, like southeast Asia, Vietnam, Thailand, south of China and even Central America, with european cows, where I have even seen a 50 per cent ratio.
Q: Do you think there is noticeable improvement in cooling around the world?
A: I think that only a very small part of the countries where there is an intensive dairy cattle activity, with pure and specialized breeds, manage to do it. So I believe there's a lot to be done with this issue, which is relatively new. Wherever I go, people try to cool off cows, but very few of the barns accomplish it because it is not well done or they don't follow the requirements.
We also need to remember that, even though what we do is try to help the cow, its well-being, and health, this is a business and people have to make a living out of this, so the economic aspect is important. In every project that I'm involved with we have to calculate costs and benefits. We have to consider the economic potential of cooling cows and I consider it the most profitable investment for a producer in warm weather. In most cases, the net income per cow a year is doubled. This helps increase profits. The return of investment can be full in two years and there are cases of only one year.
Dr. Flamenbaum started working with dairy cows in the late sixties, as an herd man and then, in charge of the 150 dairy cows herd in Kibbutz Misgav Am, in the north of Israel. Then he joined the State of Israel, Ministry of agriculture, Extension services in 1977.Since 1977 until 2008 - Serving in different positions, starting as a dairy cattle regional extension officer, head of cattle department and lately, as the director of the division of Animal Husbandry.In April 2008, he retired and dedicated professional activity time as private consultant in Israel and worldwide.
February 23, 2017
Oh, I see! My small herd is in Northern Thailand, in the mountains. The weather is cooler than on the plain, but April and may can be hot (40-44oC). The walls are open, cement floors, that we clean with running water in a hose twice a day, a shower in passing to the cows. Would a mist and a fan help? 10 minutes per hour? Or would you recommend a shower like sprinkler? We have plenty of clean drinkable water coming from 2 deep wells.
star Israel Flamenbaum Israel Flamenbaum
PhD (Animal Science)
February 23, 2017


In Thailand condition I do recommend the direct cooling which combines wetting and forced ventilation.
Anyhow, there is need to know specific farm conditions to give the exact recommendation about the time of cooling needed.

Tamas Csaki Dvm Tamas Csaki Dvm
Veterinary doctor
March 2, 2017

Dear Mr. Flamenbaum,

You got around one of the questions of the reporter. The question was: You have researched Summer to Winter ratio. What would be a good ratio?
I am working in Hungary and in the surrounding countries. Mostly, there is a big difference in winter and summer temperature, mainly in the last years, thanks to the changes in the climate conditions. As far as I understood, the question was directed towards to the structure of the TMR. Digestability, fermentability, fat and fiber ratio, components preventing heat production in the rumen during rumination etc. Have you have any new information or suggestions out of your experimental work, to use more heat-stress-preventing components in the TMR during the hot period of the year?

Tamas, Csaki DVM.

star Israel Flamenbaum Israel Flamenbaum
PhD (Animal Science)
March 3, 2017

Dear Tamas,

feeding manipulation in summer diets, mainly reducing fiber, adding fats and increase energy and protein concentration have limited potential to improve cows performance in heat stress conditions. the most can be reached by intensive cooling the cows in this period.

Rajeshwaran Rajeshwaran
March 5, 2017
This subject is very breed specific. Specifically, the Indian breed of cows and buffaloes may have a very different temperature humidity comfort zone for optimal production.
Cedden Cedden
Agricultural Engineer
March 16, 2017
Dear Mr. Flamenbaum,

Thank you very much for your informative article. Decreased milk yield performance is more striking in Western Europe derived cattle breeds. It is worth to study closer the experience with Zebu or Shaival derived breeds in some countries located in tropical and sub-tropical zones such as Brazil and India. Besides, disease and parasite resistance become important in hot periods. The question is that to insist with high producing breeds or to confine our selves with those producing reasonable milk yield.
star Israel Flamenbaum Israel Flamenbaum
PhD (Animal Science)
March 16, 2017
Dear Mr. Cedden,

I totally agree with you when it comes to tropical conditions with restricted possibilities to control deseases.
My article is refered more to intensified farms with Europeran breeds located in warm regions, as for example my country Israel and your country Turkey are.
Teshome Gedefa Teshome Gedefa
March 16, 2017

Yes, it is very important to deal with such kind of issues, because most of the farmers do not know how the type of feed influence the composition of the milk and impose heat load to the animal.

April 5, 2017
Yes , Indian breeds which produce little milk ,never feel much heat stress.But HF cows produce greater milk in India and also feel a lot of heat stress.Your method is 100% right and practical.I am managing our dairy herd of 90 Holstein cows very well in peak summers in India. For practical applications of your system,a free PDF file of research by Elanco is very helpful. But nowadays in India, a special class of non- practical politicians and so called dairy professionals forcing our poor dairy farmers to leave the Holstein and feed the 3000-4000 kg per lactation milk producing Indian breeds.And that's also on small land holdings of 5-6 acre per farmer.Flamenbaum you and your prescribed cooling method is God sent for us.May God bless you.
star Israel Flamenbaum Israel Flamenbaum
PhD (Animal Science)
April 12, 2017

Thank you Mr. Jagdish for your blessings

Yes, it is possible to mitigate heat stress effectively in all climate conditions. Some other limitations are needed to be treated (not related to heat stress), such as veterinary issues, in order to reach HF potential in such climates. Wish you success with your HF cows in India.

Would you like to discuss about this topic: Flamenbaum: "Only a very small amount of countries manage to cool cows off"?
Engormix reserves the right to delete and/or modify comments. See more details

Comments that contain the following items won´t be published:

  • Repeated spelling mistakes.
  • Advertisements, Web sites and/or e-mail addresses.
  • Questions or answers not relevant to the topic discussed in the Forum.
You need to be part of Engormix to post a comment on this discussion
Post a comment
Professional Services
Dr. Christian Rippe DVM Dr. Christian Rippe DVM
Spring Hill, Florida, Estados Unidos de América
Fernando Diaz, DVM, PhD Fernando Diaz, DVM, PhD
Brookings, South Dakota, United States
Steve Blezinger Steve Blezinger
Sulphur Springs, Texas, United States
Jasmer Singh Jasmer Singh
Rocklin, California, United States
Copyright © 1999-2017 Engormix - All Rights Reserved