INTRODUCTION
Aiming at reducing production costs and the impacts of animal production waste on the environment, research has focused on improving the efficiency of feed utilization.One strategy to reduce the excretion of pollutant compounds is to increase the nutritional availability of feeds by the dietary supplementation of exogenous enzymes (Nahm, 2002). Phytase, for instance, allows reducing inorganic phosphorus supplementation and increasing phytic acid utilization by the birds, thereby reducing phosphorus excretion with no effect on live performance.
Phytase has been widely used in broiler feeds to partially release phosphorus, calcium, and other minerals that are bound as phytate in feedstuffs. According to Borges et al. (1997), phytase increases phosphorus availability in approximately 50%, and reduces its fecal and urinary excretion in similar proportions. Recent studies demonstrated that dietary nutrient levels can be reduced, while maintaining broiler performance and minimizing the excretion of some elements (Silva et al., 2006; Silva et al., 2008; Gomide et al., 2007; Nagata, 2006; Nagata et al., 2009).
Therefore, the aim of the present study was to evaluate the effect of two calcium levels in diets supplemented with three phytase levels on nutrient metabolizability and excretion, as well as to determined AMEn during the starter (1-21 days), grower (29-35 days), and finisher (36-42 days) phases.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Three metabolism assays were performed at the experimental poultry house of the Department of Animal Nutrition and Production of FMVZ, USP, Brazil. A number of 108 male AG Ross 308 broilers was used in each rearing phase (starter, grower, and finisher). Broilers were reared until 15, 29, and 36 days, respectively, in a masonry broilers house on woodshavings litter, where they were fed the experimental diets. At the above-mentioned ages, birds were transferred to battery cages, under a lighting regime of 24h continuous light. Cages were made of stainless steel and equipped with trough feeders, nipple drinkers, and collection trays.
A completely randomized experimental design in a 3 x 2 factorial arrangement, with three phytase levels (0, 600 or 1200 FTU/kg) and two calcium levels (0.94 and 0.66%; 0.84 and 0.59%; e 0.78 and 0.54% in the starter, grower, and finisher phases, respectively) was applied.
Diets contained equal nutrient levels in each rearing phase, except for calcium levels, were based on corn and soybean meal, and were formulated according to the recommendations of Rostagno et al. (2005). In all feeds, available phosphorus levels were reduced in 30% in the different phases (Tables 1, 2, and 3). Calcium and phytase levels were adjusted by increasing or reducing limestone and enzyme levels at the expense of inert material (kaolin). The phytase product was derived from fermentation of a non-pathogenic strain of Aspergillusniger.
Water and feed were offered ad libitum. A lighting regime of 24 hours of light was adopted.
The metabolism assay included four days of adaptation and three days of total excreta collection (Rodrigues et al., 2005). At the end of the each metabolism assay, excreta were homogenized, weighed, an aliquot was dried in a forced-ventilation oven at 55°C until constant weight, ground, and prepared for analyses.
The analyses were carried out at the Chemical Analyses Laboratory of VNP and at CPPSE Embrapa. Gross energy in the feed and excreta samples was determined in a calorimetric bomb (Ika-Werke C5000). Nitrogen levels were determined according to the method of Kjeldahl. Calcium and phosphorus levels were determined by atomic absorption spectrophotometry. Feed AMEn values were calculated using the equations described by Matterson et al. (1965).
Metabolism parameter data were analyzed by the PROC MEANS procedures of the software program Statistical Analysis System, version 9.1.3 (SAS, 1995). As recommended by Banzatto & Kronka (2006), the variables expressed as percentage were submitted to arcsin root transformation, and then to analysis of variance and multiple comparison procedure. However, as there were no differences between transformed and raw data, the raw data are presented.
When there was significant effect (p≤0.05) of calcium levels only, the Student’s t-test was used to compared the means when there was a significant effect (p≤0.05) of phytase levels, regression analyses were performed using the most significant complex model (linear or quadratic), independently of calcium levels. When interactions were significant (P≤0.05), details of the interactions were submitted to the F test, and when required, analyses of regression of the effects of phytase within each calcium level were performed.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Treatments did not influence energy utilization by the broilers during the starter phase (Table 4).There was a linear effect of phytase levels on apparent metabolizable energy corrected for nitrogen balance (AMEn) during the grower phase when the diets contained high calcium level (p< 0.01): the highest phytase inclusion level, the highest the AMEn level obtained (Table 5).During the same period, there was a quadratic effect of phytase inclusion (p< 0.01) when the low-calcium diets were fed. Based on the first derivative of the quadratic equation, an optimal phytase level of 598.71 FTU/kg was calculated, which promoted the highest AMEn value when low calcium was fed during the grower phase. During the finisher phase, only calcium levels affected AMEn values (p< 0.05), with the broilers fed the high-calcium diet presenting the highest AMEn values. The optimal phytase level calculated from the equation was 785 FTU/kg.
Silva et al. (2008) reported high AMEn values in feeds containing low crude protein (CP) and available phosphorus (AvP) levels, suggesting that supplementing broiler feeds with phytase and synthetic amino acids allows reducing dietary CP, AvP, and Ca levels and improving dietary energy levels.
Namkung & Leeson (1999) and Ravindran et al. (2001), obtained improvements of 1.0 and 2.3% in AMEn energy values in 1- to 25-d-old and 1- to 28-d-old broilers, respectively, with the addition of phytase to the feeds. Santos (2008) verified that broilers fed diets with reduced calcium and available phosphorus levels and phytase addition presented adequate AMEn levels, which were not different or even higher compared with the control treatment that contained the nutritional levels recommended by Rostagno et al. (2005).
Rocha et al. (2006) did not find any AMEn differences when phytase was supplemented to diets with reduced Ca and AvP levels, demonstrating the positive effect of the enzyme when AvP was reduced up to 0.35% in the diet of 1- to 7-d-old broilers.
There were significant effects of the treatments on nitrogen intake (N Int) during the three rearing phases (Tables 6 and 7). In the starter phase, there were interactions in the quadratic model (p< 0.01) between calcium and phytase levels both for high and low calcium levels. Considering the three evaluated phytase levels, birds fed low-calcium diets presented higher nitrogen intake than those fed the high-calcium diet, and for both calcium levels, nitrogen intake increased with increasing phytase levels.
There was a linear interaction between calcium and phytase levels (p< 0.01) during the grower phase. In the finisher phase, there was a quadratic effect (p< 0.01) for phytase levels, with increasing N Int as phytase level increased in the high-calcium diets, and the opposite effect when the low-calcium diets were fed. As to calcium levels, broilers fed the high-calcium diets presented higher N Int. Silva et al. (2008) reported that nitrogen intake was reduced when broilers were fed reduced CP, AvP, and Ca diets supplemented with phytase.
Nitrogen excretion (N Exc) results and equations are shown in Tables 8 and 9, respectively. There were linear responses in the starter (p< 0.05) and in the grower (p< 0.01) phases for phytase levels. Opposite to the expectations, increasing phytase levels determined increasing N Exc. Also, during the grower phase, the quadratic equation best explained the results obtained with the high-calcium diets, estimating an optimal level of 611 FTU/kg of dietary phytase supplementation. No effects of treatments (p > 0.05) on nitrogen excretion in the finisher phase.
These results do not agree with the findings of (2006) and Silva et al. (2008) reported a significant decrease in both nitrogen intake and excretion in broilers fed diets with reduced CP and AvP levels supplemented with phytase. Silva et al. (2006) did not find any differences in nitrogen excretion when evaluating different CP and AvP levels in diets with phytase in 1- to 21-d-old broilers.
Tables 10 and 11 present the results and the equations, respectively, relative to the coefficient of nitrogen retention (N Ret). Nitrogen retention coefficient in the grower phase was significantly influenced (p< 0.01) both by calcium and phytase levels.
The coefficient of nitrogen retention of the broilers fed the high-calcium diets was lower relative to those fed the low-calcium diet. Phytase levels resulted in different quadratic responses, with a concave curve for the birds fed high calcium levels and a convex curve for those fed the low calcium level. The optimal phytase level in low-calcium diets for nitrogen retention was calculated in 750 FTU/kg, and 791 FTU/kg was estimated for the lowest nitrogen retention when high-calcium diets were fed. Considering that higher nitrogen retention indicates better nitrogen utilization, and consequently, lower nitrogen excretion in the environment, both reducing dietary calcium levels and adding an optimal level of phytase (750 FTU/kg) are favorable.
In the finisher phase, a quadratic effect of phytase (p< 0.01) was observed; however, no optimal equation to explain this response was found. It was observed also in the grower phase that different results were obtained with the tested calcium levels: the broilers fed the high-calcium diets presented increasing nitrogen retention with increasing dietary phytase supplementation, whereas those fed the low-calcium diets reduced nitrogen retention as phytase levels increased.
The higher nitrogen retention coefficient in broilers fed reduced crude protein levels may be related to the dietary addition of phytase. Phytic acid may bind the enzymes trypsin and pepsin (Mroz et al., 1994), forming phytate-protein or phytate-mineral-protein complexes (Ravindran & Bryden, 1997) that may affect dietary protein digestibility. Therefore, the hydrolysis of the phosphorus-protein bond by phytase enhances amino acid digestion and absorption (Ravindran & Bryden, 1997). Camden et al. (2001) reported apparent N retention in broilers increased with the addition of phytase to diets containing reduced AvP and Ca levels. However, the findings of the present study do not agree with those studies, as dietary phytase addition did not have a positive effect on nitrogen retention. Silva et al. (2008) and Ibrahim et al. (1999) also did not obtain any improvements in N utilization in starter broilers supplemented with phytase.
Relative to phosphorus intake, the quadratic model showed an interaction between calcium and phytase levels in the starter (p< 0.01) and in the grower (p< 0.001) phases, as shown in Table 12. In the finisher phase, only calcium levels significantly affected phosphorus intake.
In the starter phase, there was a quadratic effect of high-calcium diets (Table 13) on phosphorus intake, with an estimated optimal phytase level of 900 FTU/ kg. Phytase level promoted an increasing linear effect on phosphorus intake, i.e., the higher the phytase inclusion level, the higher the intake of phosphorus. In addition, the broilers fed the low-calcium diet, except for diet that did not contain phytase, presented higher calcium intake than those fed the high-calcium diet.
In the period of 22-35 days of age, there was a quadratic influence of both calcium levels on phosphorus intake, but high-calcium diets had a stronger influence. Using the first derivative of the regression equation, the optimal phytase addition for P Int was 473.68 FTU/kg in the high-calcium diets, where as for the low-calcium diet, the optimal phytase level was estimated in 315.80 FTU/kg.
In the period of 36-42 days of age, broilers fed high-calcium diets had higher phosphorus intake than those supplied with low-calcium diets.
There was no effect of treatments (p> 0.05) on phosphorus excretion (P Exc), as shown in Table 14. Different results were obtained by Wyatt & Harker (1995), who observed 12-15% reduction in P excretion when adding phytase to broiler diets. Silva (2004) reported more than 50% reduction in relative P excretion during the starter phase when broilers were fed a diet containing 0.34% available phosphorus supplemented with 500 FTU/kg feed. Nagata et al. (2009) obtained 24.7% phosphorus excretion reduction in broilers fed diets with reduced CP and AvP levels supplemented with phytase.
Silva et al. (2006) observed that reduced CP levels, independently of AvP levels, and high CP level associated with reduced AvP level, both associated with phytase supplementation, reduced P excretion.
Gomide (2006) and Silva (2004) reported significant reduction in phosphorus intake and excretion when broilers were fed low crude protein and available phosphorus levels supplemented with phytase compared with the control diet, all of which contained 3000 kcal AMEn/kg.
As shown in Table 15, there was a linear effect of the interaction (p< 0.01) between the calcium and phytase levels evaluated in the starter phase for phosphorus retention. Despite the significant effect of treatments, there was no significant regression equation for this parameter or for the curvilinear effect (p< 0.01) of the interaction observed in the phase of 22-35 days of age.
In the period of 36-42 days of age, dietary calcium levels influenced (p< 0.05) phosphorus retention, with the birds fed the low-calcium level diets presenting higher phosphorus retention coefficient than those supplied with the high-calcium levels.
Silva (2004) reported 11.2% improvement in phosphorus retention when broilers were fed a diet with 0.34% available phosphorus supplemented with 500 FTU/kg in the starter phase.
Fukayama et al. (2008) observed that phytase supplementation improved phosphorus digestibility in a diet with reduced ME, CP, AvP, and Ca, and a linear increase in phosphorus utilization. The dietary supplementation of 750 and 1,000 FTU/kg of phytase promoted better digestibility coefficients than those obtained with the diet with reduced ME, CP, AvP, and Ca with no enzyme supplementation. According to Sebastian et al. (1996), phytase breaks down the phytate-mineral complex, releasing minerals for absorption, thereby reducing their excretion and increasing their digestibility. However, Oliveira et al. (2008) did not observe any effect of phytase on P retention.
Table 16 shows calcium intake (Ca Int) results and Table 17, the respective regression equations.
In the three studied phases, there was a quadratic interaction (p< 0.05) between factors, and in all phases, the broilers fed the high-calcium diet presented higher Ca Int.
In the starter period, Ca Int linearly increased with increasing phytase levels in broilers fed both calcium levels.
In the grower phase, there as a convex quadratic response, with an estimated optima level of phytase addition of 543.75 FTU/kg for the birds fed the high-calcium diet, and an increasing linear response for those fed the low-calcium diet. The same behavior was observed in the finisher phase.
Silva et al. (2008) observed reduced Ca Int when broiler were fed diets with low CP and AvP levels supplemented with phytase.
Quadratic interactions (p< 0.001) between the evaluated factors were also found for calcium excretion (Ca Exc) in the three studied phases (Table 18), but no significant regression equation was obtained.
In all phases, Ca Exc was higher in the birds fed the high-calcium diet. In the starter phase, there was an increasing curvilinear response in Ca Exc as dietary phytase level increased when broilers were fed the high-calcium diet. There was a concave curvilinear response when broilers were supplied with the low-calcium diet.
In the periods of 22-35 and 36-42 days of age, the birds fed the high-calcium diet presented a convex curvilinear response, where as a decreasing curvilinear response was obtained with increasing phytase levels in the grower phase and a concave curvilinear response in the finisher phase for those fed the low-calcium diet.
Silva et al. (2006) reported that phytase efficiently reduced Ca excretion when associated with low CP and AvP levels or with high CP and low AvP levels.
The findings of Nagata et al.(2009) demonstrated that reduced dietary CP, AvP, and Ca levels associated with phytase supplementation reduced Ca intake, but not Ca excretion, as previously observed by Silva (2004). The authors attribute these results to the fact that the concentration of phytase in the diet was probably not sufficient to break the phytate-mineral bond and therefore, to release calcium for absorption.
The Table 19 shows the coefficients of calcium retention (CR Ca). Consistent with the calcium intake and excretion results, calcium retention was also affected by non-linear interactions (p< 0.01) in the three studied phases.
In the starter phase, calcium retention in broilers fed both calcium levels linearly increased with increasing phytase levels, and those supplied with the low-calcium level presented higher calcium retention than those fed the high-calcium diet. However, a significant regression equation explaining this result was obtained only for those fed the low-calcium diet (Table 20).
In the period of 22-35 days of age, low-calcium levels promoted higher calcium retention than the high Ca levels.
An increasing linear equation described the increasing Ca retention with increasing dietary phytase levels in broilers fed the low Ca level, whereas a convex quadratic equation described the response of those fed the high Ca level, with an estimated optimal phytase level of 500 FTU/kg for the best Ca retention.
Although a quadratic interaction was observed for the period of 36-42 days of age, no equations describing the results were obtained. There was an increasing curvilinear response of the birds fed the high Ca level, and a convex curvilinear response for those fed the low Ca level. The broilers supplied with the low Ca level presented better calcium retention coefficient compared with those fed the high Ca level.
Oliveira et al. (2008) verified better Ca retention with dietary phytase supplementation, demonstrating the effect of phytate hydrolysis, thereby making Ca more available for absorption. These results are consistent with the findings of Tejedor et al. (2001), Viveros et al. (2002), and Rutherfurd et al. (2004), who worked with non-phytic phosphorus levels ranging between 0.33 and 0.37% and phytase levels of 0, 500, and 750 FTU/ kg diet.
Nagata et al. (2009) obtained lower calcium retention coefficients with diets with extreme CP levels supplemented with phytase, which were similar to those obtained with the control diet, containing 17% CP, also supplemented with phytase. Silva (2004) also observed a reduction in calcium retention, but only when feeds contained 19.0% CP. That author inferred that phytase was no efficient to improve calcium utilization or perhaps the improvement in calcium digestibility caused changes in Ca:P ratio, which may have caused the lower retention of calcium.
CONCLUSIONS
Reducing dietary calcium levels to 0.66, 0.59, and 0.54%, and using 0.27, 0.22, and 0.20% available phosphorus, 18.50, 17.50, and 16.00% crude protein, and 600 FTU phytase/kg in the diets of the starter, grower, and finisher phases, respectively, allow higher nitrogen, phosphorus, and calcium retention in broilers. Energy utilization is not influenced by dietary calcium or phytase levels in the starter phase. However, in the grower phase, increasing phytase levels improve AMEn utilization, and the best results in the finisher phase were presented by the broilers fed the high calcium level.
