Engormix
Home
Search
Explore
Publish
Explore
Communities in English
AquacultureMycotoxinsPoultry IndustryPig IndustryDairy CattleAnimal Feed
AgriculturaBalanceados - PiensosAviculturaGanaderíaLecheríaMicotoxinasPorciculturaMascotas
MicotoxinasAviculturaSuinoculturaPecuária de cortePecuária de leite
Advertise on Engormix
Home
Publish
Search
Engormix.com / Poultry Industry / Amino acids in poultry nutrition

Similar laying hens performance between methionine sources under tropical conditions

Published: March 20, 2020
By: RAMA RAO S. V.¹, RAJU M.V.L.N¹, NAGALAKSHMI D.¹, PRAKASH B.¹, BATONONALAVO D. I.² & MERCIER Y.² ¹Sri Ramadhootha Poultry Research Farm Pvt Ltd, Kothur 501 359, India, ²Adisseo France S.A.S., Antony Park II, 92160 Antony. dolores.batonon-alavo@adisseo.com
Abstract
A study was performed to compare the effects of dietary supplementation of DL-Methionine (DL-Met) or Hydroxy-Methionine (OH-Met) at the requirement in sulfur amino acids on laying hen’s performance under tropical summer season. Four-hundred and forty-eight Babcock layers were randomly allocated based on their body weight in two treatments of 14 replicates each (16 hens per replicate). Hens were offered either DL-Met or OH-Met at the requirement from week 18 to 31 weeks of age. Body weight increased with age and was not significantly different between treatments. Feed intakes were lower than breed standards, as influenced by heat stress but were similar between the two sources of methionine. There were no significant differences between egg mass, egg weight and feed conversion ratio of hens fed OH-Met or DL-Met. Similarly, egg density, eggshell strength and Haugh units were not significantly different between methionine sources. This study demonstrated that DL-Met and OH-Met are similar in laying hens under tropical conditions.
Introduction and objectives
Methionine (Met) is the first limiting amino acid in poultry species. It is available as LMethionine, DL-methionine (DL-Met) and hydroxy-methionine (OH-Met). The addition of Met in the poultry feed industry is still facing the relative efficacy dilemma between DL-Met and OH-Met (BUNCHASAK et al., 2012; NIE et al., 2007). In laying hens, only few studies have been performed to compare these two sources in tropical conditions. Therefore, the aim of the present study is to compare the effects of dietary supplementation of DL-Met or OH-Met at the requirement in sulfur amino acids on laying hen’s performance under tropical conditions.
Materials and methods
Four-hundred and forty-eight Babcock layers were reared from 18 to 31 weeks in collective cages in an open-sided facility at Sri Ramadhootha Poultry Research Farm Pvt Ltd, India. Birds were randomly allocated to two treatments with 14 replicates of 16 hens each. The egg mass and feed intake usually observed in the facility were used as factors to calculate the amino acids recommendations, based on the Rhodimet nutrition guide recommendations (Adisseo). Corn and soybean meal-based diets were supplemented on equimolar doses with either DL-Met or OH-Met, respectively at 0.14% and 0.16% (Table 1). Birds were habituated to the experimental diets from 18 to 20 weeks and data was collected from 21 to 31 weeks. Laying hens had free access to feed and water during the whole trial.
Similar laying hens performance between methionine sources under tropical conditions - Image 1
Temperature (Min. 18.3°C; Max. 39.3°C) and relative humidity (Min. 20%; Max. 90%) varied widely along the day and throughout the experimental period (Figure). Body weight was measured at the end of week 17, 23 and 28. Feed intake, egg production, egg weight, egg mass and feed conversion rate were measured on a weekly basis. Data was analyzed with a one-way ANOVA, respectively for the periods: weeks 21-25, and 26-31. Data of the overall experimental period (Week 21-31) was submitted to a repeated-measures ANOVA with the treatment and age as variables. Egg quality parameters were measured at week 22, 26 and 30, taking one egg per replicate per treatment (n=14), and were submitted to an ANCOVA model using the age and the treatment as variables (XLSTAT, Version 2015.3.01.19199).
Figure. Evolution of temperature and relative humidity throughout the trial
Similar laying hens performance between methionine sources under tropical conditions - Image 2
Results and Discussion
Body weight of laying hens increased linearly with age (P < 0.001) and was not significantly (P = 0.52) different between DL-Met (1258 ± 119 g/b) and OH-Met (1269 ± 122 g/b). This is in accordance with the results observed by (AGOSTINI et al., 2016) and (ZHAO et al., 2018), indicating that DL-Met and OH-Met similarly sustain bird’s growth. Table 2 shows the evolution of laying performance with age for the two groups. All parameters were improved with age (P < 0.001). However, feed intake, egg production, egg weight and egg mass were below the references of Babcock as the result of the high temperature and variable relative humidity (RENAUDEAU et al., 2012; CHENG et al., 1990). As demonstrated by (DANIEL AND BALNAVE, 1981), when temperatures gradually rise and remain high for an extended period, birds can acclimatize and maintain egg production and body weight at satisfactory levels. However, heat changes on a short period jeopardize birds’ ability to acclimatize. Additionally, a high relative humidity hampers adaptation to extreme of temperatures (DANIEL AND BALNAVE, 1981; CHENG et al., 1990). In addition, all the laying performance criteria were similar between DL-Met and OH-Met throughout the experimental period. These results are in accordance with (BUNCHASAK et al., 2012; CUEVAS et al., 2001) who showed that the two sources can be equally used to ensure laying hens performance. 
Similar laying hens performance between methionine sources under tropical conditions - Image 3
Egg quality parameters are presented Table 3. Egg density, Haugh unit, shell weight and shell thickness were affected by the age but they were similar between DL-Met and OH-Met. Egg strength was neither affected by the age, nor by the dietary treatment. Therefore, the supplementation of DL-Met and OH-Met did not impact egg quality under tropical conditions.
Similar laying hens performance between methionine sources under tropical conditions - Image 4 
Conclusion
There is no significant difference of layers’ body weights between treatments indicating that DL-Met and OH-Met similarly sustain hen’s growth performance. There is no significant difference between DL-Met and OH-Met in all criteria of performance and on egg quality parameters. Overall, this study shows that OH-Met is as efficient as DL-Met as source of supplemental Met in laying hens diets under tropical climate. 
This extended abstract has been presented at the 22nd European Symposium on Poultry Nutrition, 10-13 June 2019 Gdansk, Poland and is available in the proceedings of the conference.

AGOSTINI, P.S., DALIBARD, P., MERCIER, Y., VAN DER AAR, P. & VAN DER KLIS, J.D. (2016). Comparison of methionine sources around requirement levels using a methionine efficacy method in 0 to 28 day old broilers. Poultry Science 95: 560–569.

BUNCHASAK, C., RATCHADAPORNVANITCH, Y. & THIENGTHAM, J. (2012). Comparative effects of supplemental DL-2-hydroxy-4-[methylthio] butanoic acid and DLmethionine in diet on egg production and quality in laying hens. Journal of Poultry Science 49: 260–267.

CHENG, T.K., COON, C.N. & HAMRE, M.L. (1990). Effect of environmental stress on the ascorbic acid requirement of laying hens. Poultry Science 69: 774–780.

CUEVAS, A.C., PARODI, F.J.D. & GONZALEZ, E.A. (2001). Production performance of egg laying hens fed diets supplemented with two sources of synthetic methionine. Veterinaria Mexico 32: 183–187.

DANIEL, M. & BALNAVE, D. (1981). Responses of laying hens to gradual and abrupt increases in ambient temperature and humidity. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 21: 189.

NIE, W., GUO, Y.-M., YANG, Y., YUAN, J.-M. & WANG, Z. (2007). Comparison of the efficacy of methionine and its hydroxy analog in diets of laying hens. Zhongguo Xumu Zazhi 43: 22–24.

RENAUDEAU, D., COLLIN, A., YAHAV, S., BASILIO, V. DE, GOURDINE, J.L. & COLLIER, R.J. (2012). Adaptation to hot climate and strategies to alleviate heat stress in livestock production. Animal : an international journal of animal bioscience 6: 707–728.

ZHAO, L., ZHANG, N.-Y., PAN, Y.-X., ZHU, L.-Y., BATONON-ALAVO, D.I., MA, L.-B., KHALIL, M.M., QI, D.-S. & SUN, L.-H. (2018). Efficacy of 2-hydroxy-4- methylthiobutanoic acid compared to DL-Methionine on growth performance, carcass traits, feather growth, and redox status of Cherry Valley ducks. Poultry Science Sep 1; 97(9):3166- 317.

Related topics
#Amino acids in poultry nutrition
Authors:
Dolores Batonon-Alavo
Dolores Batonon-Alavo
Adisseo
1Recommendations
1Comments
·
489Views
Recommend
Comment
Share
Juarez Donzele
Juarez Donzele
Universidade Federal de Viçosa - UFV
25 de marzo de 2020

Dr. Yves, results of studies we conducted with layers, and those of some literature data, which were consistent with ours, showed that the relationship. met + cist.dig: lysine dig, which corresponded to 100: 100, provided the best performance results for birds. Based on these considerations, I found that in the ration used in your work the relationship between these amino acids was below that relationship, which leads to the deduction that probably the level of dig lysine. used may be overestimated. My considerations do not invalidate your study and do not have this claim. What we are aiming for with these statements is to encourage more researchers in this line of research. This has relevance, considering that the level of dig lysine. really overestimated, in addition to correcting it, there would be a need to reevaluate the relationships of the other essential amino acids with lysine to establish the ideal protein for the category under study.

1
Recommend
Reply
Profile picture
Would you like to discuss another topic? Create a new post to engage with experts in the community.
Join Engormix and be part of the largest agribusiness social network in the world.