1. Introduction
Under normal circumstances, excessive free radicals are scavenged by body enzymatic and non-enzymatic antioxidants, but oxidative stress can occur when the amount of oxidant production surpasses the capacity of the body’s antioxidant system [1,2]. Different aspects of avian productive and reproductive performances, such as egg production rate and egg quality traits, as well as fertility and hatchability may be adversely influenced by oxidative stress.
Selenium (Se) is the key constituent of several seleno-proteins and enzymes involved in antioxidant system, DNA repair, fertility, and productive traits [3]. There are both organic and inorganic compounds of Se in nature. Selenomethionine is the main form of organic selenium, whereas sodium selenite (Na2SeO3) is an inorganic source of selenium. Regardless of the fact that Se requirement of birds can usually be met by corn and soybean meal diets, dietary sodium selenite up to 0.5 mg kg−1 (maximum level) is usually recommended to improve avian health and productive performance [4]. Sel-Plex (SP) is a commercial name for organic selenium that is characterized by yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae growth in Selenium-rich culture medium [5]. Birds cannot synthesize selenomethionine by an effective mechanism, and therefore rely on grass and forage crops that transform selenium primarily into selenomethionine and incorporate this into nitrogen components instead of methionine [5]. Unlike inorganic selenium, with intestinal passive absorption, selenomethionine is actively absorbed through the mechanism used for the absorption of methionine. Higher duodenal absorption and deposition in the liver make organic selenium an interesting Se source in laying hens to meet their requirement without sacrificing performance [6]. In addition, lower excretion rate and the ability to incorporate into the structure of proteins provides the body with a natural and reversible source of selenium storage [7,8]. On the other hand, organic selenium seems more effective than the inorganic form in improving egg quality [9] and bird immunity [10]. Mobaraki and Shahryar [11] showed that dietary selenium (0.4 mg/kg) and vitamin E (160 mg/kg) had no significant effect on feed intake, shell thickness, the weight of egg whites and the percentage of egg hatchability stored for seven days. However, they reported that the treatments of the study did not have significant impacts on other features, i.e., egg production percentage, feed conversion ratio, eggshell percentage, yolk weight percentage, international quality unit (IQU), Haugh unit, and percentage egg hatchability in 10 days storage. Previous studies have reported Selenium supplementation of Japanese quail diets improved the egg shelf life during storage period by improving HU and decreasing yolk fat peroxidation [12].
Vitamin E (VE) is the main antioxidant in egg yolk lipid terminating the lipid peroxidation chain by reacting with lipid peroxides and making them stable [2]. The use of excess dietary vitamin E in poultry’ feed has been shown to increase the growth performance, the meat nutritional value in terms of the fatty acid composition, and the shelf life [13]. Łukaszewicz et al. [14] determined the effect of feed supplementation with organic selenium and vitamin E on chemical composition and sensory characteristics of Japanese quail (coturnix japonica) eggs and reported that feeding Japanese quail with selenium and vitamin E reduces the concentration of fat in eggs and the concentration of cholesterol in yolk, while increasing the levels of selenium, protein, and antioxidant properties. In addition, feeding 60 IU kg−1 of VE results in improved of feed intake, laying percentage and egg quality traits including Haugh unit, egg weight and vitelline membrane strength [15]. There is undoubtedly a strong relationship between Se and VE in terms of protecting cells against free radical damage [3]. Moreover, their metabolisms are closely interrelated since the absorption of vitamin E is impaired in birds during Se deficiency [16]. Dietary Se also increases VE content of plasma, egg yolk and meat of chickens [17]. Therefore, it is not surprising that researchers have focused on applying the Se and VE together in their studies.
The beneficial effects of Se and VE on the rate of egg production and fresh and stored egg quality traits have been extensively studied in laying hens [18,19] but information regarding the potential benefits of these antioxidants on the productive performance of Japanese quails is limited. Thus, the current experiment was conducted to survey the effectiveness of different VE (30 or 120 mg kg−1) and selenium sources (organic or inorganic) on the fresh or stored egg quality parameters and productive performance in Japanese quails.
2. Materials and Methods
The experimental protocols were recorded according to the regulations for the use of experimental animals and approved by the Ethical Committee for Use of Laboratory Animals of University of Tabriz (Approved number: IR.TABRIZU.REC.1399.035).
2.1. Chemical Agents and Experimental Design
All chemicals with the purity of >99% (analytical grade) were prepared from Merck (Darmstadt, Germany). Selenium and vitamin E were purchased from Sigma Aldrich (SEM-AZ, Baku, Azerbaijan).
A total of 300 female 12-week-old Japanese quails with similar body weight and production rate were randomly distributed into five groups with four replicates of fifteen birds in each. Birds were group caged in a well-ventilated room under 8:16 dark: light lighting regime. Animals received water and feed ad libitum throughout the study. Treatment groups consisted of basal diet (control), basal diet addition 30 mg of VE and 0.4 mg kg−1 sodium selenite (VE30SS), basal diet addition 30 mg of VE and 0.4 mg kg−1 of Sel-Plex (VE30SP), basal diet addition 120 mg of VE and 0.4 mg kg−1 of Sodium selenite (VE120SS) and basal diet addition 120 mg of VE and 0.4 mg kg−1 of Sel-Plex (VE120SP). Sodium selenite (containing 46% Se), Sel-Plex (containing 0.1% Se), and vitamin E (α-tocopherol acetate) were included in the feed via premix. The basal diet (Table 1) was formulated according to recommendation of NRC [20].
2.2. Determination of Productive Traits and Egg Quality
Egg production rate, egg weight and feed consumption were recorded week by week, whereas feed conversion rate and egg mass were determined at the end of experimental period. For an accurate evaluate of the interior and exterior fresh egg quality traits, six eggs were randomly gathered from each replicate treatment at the end of weeks 2, 4, 6, and 8 (a sum of 24 eggs of each treatment). Stored egg parameters were evaluated on eggs (n = 24 eggs of each treatment) collected at the end of trial (week 8) and were then stored for 15 or 30 days at 5 or 22 °C. Measurements were made according to the equations presented in the footnote of Table 2. Using 0.01 mm digital caliper, egg width and height and subsequently shape index were determined. Eggs from each treatment were weighed one by one and all of them broken open onto a flat plate.
Thick albumen height was measured using a 0.01 mm digital caliper. Haugh unit for each egg was calculated using data of egg weight and albumen height. In order to determine eggshell percentage, eggshells after washing with warm water were dried at 100 °C for 4 h and weighed with a 0.01 g in an electronic digital balance. Shell thickness measuring gauge was used to estimate shell thickness at 3 different unique focuses (blunt, equator and sharp end).
Egg yolk and egg albumen pH were determined on fresh and stored eggs. Briefly, egg content was separated to yolk and albumen using an egg separator. Individual egg yolk color was measured by using Roche color fan. Then, they were poured into different glass beakers, homogenized with a stirring bar, and finally their pH value was measured with a standard pH-meter. At the end of 8-week trial period, the yolk of all eggs in each experimental replicate were mixed together and egg yolk selenium and malondialdehyde concentrations assayed on fresh and stored eggs, respectively. To determine Se concentration, briefly, yolk samples were processed in a blend of H2O2 and HNO3 in Teflon High-pressure vessels in an MDS-2000 microwave oven. After mineralization, Se concentration was quantified by electro thermal atomizer in a graphite cuvette, employing the solar M6 atomic absorption spectrometer. The method was validated by analysis of the Se content of whole egg powder (NIST RM 8415) [21]. The thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARS) assay with small modification was used to measure lipid oxidation [22]. Briefly, 2 grams of homogenous yolk was mixed with 5 mL of 20% trichloroacetic acid (TCA) and 4 mL distilled water, and homogenized in a Waring Blender for 30 s at high speed. The homogenate was then centrifuged (1000 g for 20 min) and the resulting supernatant was filtered with Whatman Filter Paper (grade no. 1). Two mL of filtrated was mixed with 2 mL of thiobarbituric acid (TBA, 0.02 M) in a test tube and heated in boiling water for 20 min. After cooling, the absorbance of the resulting solution was record with a spectrophotometer at 532 nm (Jenway 6405, Staffordshire, UK).
2.3. Blood Biochemical Parameters
At the end week of experimental period (8th week), three birds were selected from each treatment groups and blood samples were collected from their neck vein. After collection, samples were carefully transferred to tubes containing K2EDTA as an anticoagulant. They were then centrifuged (1500 g, 10 min, 15 °C) and the plasma samples after separation were stored at −20 °C until analyzed for total antioxidant capacity (TAC), cholesterol and triglyceride concentrations. TAC of blood samples was assessed by using ferric reducing antioxidant power bioassay [23]. In this method, antioxidants present in the samples are used as reductants to reduce Fe3+ to Fe2+. Therefore, TAC was quantified by the response of phenanthroline and Fe2+ utilizing a spectrophotometer reset at 520 nm. A unit of TAC is characterized as the amount of antioxidants expected to increase absorbance value at 0.01 in 1 mL of blood sample at 37 °C. Blood cholesterol and triglyceride were measured by spectrophotometric instrument (JENWAY-6405), employing commercially available kits (ZiestChemie Diagnostic, Tehran, Iran).
2.4. Statistical Analysis
The experimental data including blood biochemical parameters of Japanese quails, egg yolk selenium concentration and egg quality traits of stored eggs were analyzed statistically based on a completely randomized design with ANOVA using the GLM procedure of SAS (2009). The differences among the groups were determined using Duncan’s multiple range tests. Significance was accepted at p < 0.05. Data for productive performance and fresh egg quality traits were analyzed using repeated measures analysis and the Proc Mixed procedure of SAS with 5 experimental diets, and 4 rearing phase as fixed effects. Mean differences were compared using Tukey’s tests at the p < 0.05 level.
3. Results
3.1. Production Performance
The effect of VE and Se supplementation diet on quail’s performance are present in Table 2. The egg production, feed consumption and feed conversion ratio of birds fed dietary supplementation of VE and Se for the eight-week experimental period did not differ significantly (p > 0.05).
Variation of food consumption during the eight weeks has been presented in Figure 1A. Apart from main effect of treatments, food consumption increased in all birds during the current study (Figure 1A).
Egg weight showed a tendency to improve (p = 0.05), but egg mass was not affected by Se sources and Foods various levels of vitamin E, as shown in Table 2020 2 (p > 0.05)
Figure 1. Variation of feed intake (A), albumen height (B) and Haugh unit of fresh eggs (C) from Japanese quails fed different levels of vitamin E (VE, 30 or 120 mg kg−1) and Se sources (SS, sodium selenite; SP, Sel-Plex) over a period of eight weeks. Values (means ±SEM) within the same week with uncommon letters are significantly (p < 0.05) different.
3.2. Quality Traits of Fresh and Stored Eggs
Some egg quality traits including Haugh unit, albumen height, eggshell thickness and egg surface area were significantly affected by VE or Se supplementation (p < 0.05), but other egg traits including albumen and yolk percentage, egg specific quality, yolk albumen ratio, eggshell percentage and strength and egg shape index were not influenced by VE or Se supplementation as shown in Table 2 (p > 0.05). Albumen height and Haugh unit showed a downward trend during eight experimental periods (Figure 1B,C).
Organic and inorganic form of dietary Se dose-responsively (p < 0.05) improved Se content in egg yolks, with a more effective on Se deposition according to Sel-Plex (Figure 2A). In birds fed with Sel-Plex, the Se concentration of egg yolks were 0.90 and 2.06 mg kg−1, for VE30SP and VE120SP groups, respectively. Correspondingly, egg yolk from birds fed with sodium selenite had 0.65 and 1.31 mg kg−1 Se, for VE30SS and VE120SS groups, respectively.
Figure 2. (A) egg yolk selenium concentration, (B) egg yolk MDA concentration after being stored for 30 days at 5 and 22 °C, (C) blood cholesterol concentration, (D) blood triacylglycerol concentration and (E) blood total antioxidant capacity of Japanese quails fed different levels of vitamin E (VE, 30 or 120 mg kg−1) and Se sources (SS, sodium selenite; SP, Sel-Plex). Values (means ± SEM) with uncommon letters are significantly (p < 0.05) different in each graph.
Egg yolk MDA concentration, indicative of fatty acid oxidative stability, increased during the 30 days of storage at either 5 or 22 °C with the highest value observed for those stored at ambient temperature (Figure 2B). Irrespective of treatment levels, beneficial effects were observed in all birds receiving VE and Se sources compared to control birds. Moreover, the combination VE and Sel-Plex was more effective to delay the lipid peroxidation compared to the combination of VE and sodium selenite. However, it was only VE120SP group which recorded the lowest significant yolk MDA concentration among treated groups (p < 0.05, Figure 2B).
In this study, without regard to storage room temperatures, the egg weight loss in percentage was significantly affected at both storage times with a more prominent effect in treatments with 120 mg of VE (Table 3).
3.3. Blood Parameters
Dietary VE and Se did not influence blood cholesterol concentration (Figure 2C). The concentration of plasma triacylglycerol (Figure 2D) was significantly increased only in VE30SP group (1767) compared with control (647.44) and birds fed with other combinations of VE and Se (902, 1101 and 1080, for VE30SS, VE120SS and VE120SP, respectively). The plasma total antioxidant capacity value (p < 0.05) was highest in birds fed with the combination of VE (30 or 120 mg) and Sel-Plex compared to control group (Figure 2E).
4. Discussion
The results of this study clearly indicated that dietary supplementation of VE and Se had no critical effect on feed consumption, FCR and egg production of Japanese quails (Table 2). Consistent with our results, dietary VE levels (30 or 120 mg/kg) with either organic or inorganic selenium source did not influence egg production in laying hen [19]. In addition, egg production rate was not influenced by increasing organic or inorganic level of selenium [24]. Likewise, the average daily gain, average daily feed intake, and feed conversion ratio of broiler chicks were not affected by dietary supplementation of various selenium sources [6]. However, apart from main effect of treatments, food consumption increased in all birds during the current study (Figure 1A). This effect is consistent with data reported by Skrobanek et al. [24] who observed a direct relationship between feed intake and aging. In terms of egg production, our results agreed with those observed by Mobaraki and Shahryar [11] who noticed that similar levels of VE and Se sources did not significantly affect laying rate during a period of 25 weeks. Other studies also noted that the increasing dietary vitamin E levels also have no significant effect on laying percentage [25,26]. By contrast, a significant increase in feed intake and percentage of egg production was found in hens raised at both natural (21 °C) and higher (34 °C) ambient temperatures [15].
In the current study, egg weight showed a tendency to improve (p = 0.05) by various levels of vitamin E and selenium sources (Table 2). According to Reis et al. [27] Se (from 0.15 to 0.30 mg kg−1) had no significant effect on egg weight of broiler breeders. On the contrary, Urso et al. [19] and Mobaraki and Shahryar [11] reported a higher egg weight in hens fed similar amount of VE and organic selenium. Vitamin E through its ability to protect liver and other organs integrity may preventing oxidative damage, thereby induce yolk precursor protein release which necessary to egg formation [28]. Otherwise selenium is essential for metabolism and action of thyroid hormones in body [29] that could be affect egg weight.
The most common egg quality characteristics are egg shape index, breaking strength, shell thickness, specific gravity, albumen height and weight, pH of albumen and yolk, Haugh unit and oxidative status of yolk lipids [30,31]. Despite having a significant effect on Haugh unit, albumen height, eggshell thickness, and egg surface area (p < 0.05), other egg traits were not influenced (p > 0.05) by VE or Se supplementation (Table 2). As Payne et al. [32] and Arpasova et al. [9] previously pointed out, hens consumed increasing levels of organic Se had significantly higher Haugh unit. Furthermore, according to Maysa et al. [33] Haugh unit, egg yolk index, and shell thickness were significantly higher in Sel-Plex fed hens.
Reports of the effect of VE supplementation on egg internal quality are contradictory and inconclusive. In one study, supplementation of vitamin E had no significant effect on albumen pH and eggshell thickness [25]. However, in another one, egg specific gravity, eggshell weight, and eggshell strength of laying hens were significantly increased after being fed with a diet comprised 250 mg/kg of VE [34].
Regardless of source, dietary Se supplementation was proposed to deposit more selenium in egg yolk than albumen [35]. In our study, both forms of dietary Se dose-responsively (p < 0.05) enhanced Se content in egg yolks, with a high prominence effect seen in Sel-Plex (Figure 2A). Having more efficient deposition in the organic form, selenium content of albumen-yolk and diet were directly related [3,35]. More importantly, organic selenium was reported to be much more effective than the inorganic form in maintaining egg storage quality, and most notably eggshell strength [36]. Not only is eggshell an extra Se source for developing embryos, but it also plays a physiological role in the physical protection to the embryo, by means gas exchange and ionic trade and water regulation [37]. It seems that improving fresh egg quality traits in the current study at least in part related to the Se deposition in quail’s eggs since egg quality indicators has been proposed to directly correlate with organic selenium concentration in egg [38]. Albumen height and Haugh unit showed a downward trend during our experiment (Figure 1B,C). Deteriorating effects of aging on egg quality has been noted in earlier studies. For instance, the albumen index, Haugh unit, and yolk index of eggs from 21-week-old quails were significantly lower compared to younger (12-week-old) birds [39].
Egg storage is usually inevitable prior to incubation or consumption. However, this may adversely affect egg quality, most probably through decline of carbon dioxide and raising the pH of albumen and yolk [40]. Phosvitin is a phosphoglycoprotein in egg yolk inhibiting metal-catalyzed phospholipid oxidation. It was shown that the pH-induced changes in phosvitin conformation, impairs its metal binding activity and consequently its antioxidant activity [41]. This may result in altering the oxidative stability of egg yolk phospholipids. In addition, having approximately 60% unsaturated fatty acids make egg yolk phospholipids very susceptible to lipid peroxidation during storage [42]. Seen in this light, measuring malondialdehyde (MDA) levels offers a convenient method of determining lipid peroxidation in egg yolk. In our study, irrespective of treatment levels, beneficial effects were observed in all birds receiving VE and Se sources compared to control birds. The lower values of MDA in all birds receiving VE and Se sources are probably due to selenium accumulation in egg yolk. Also, the lowest significant yolk MDA concentration in VE120SP group (p < 0.05, Figure 2B) compared to other treated groups may be due to the better accumulation of Sel-Plex in egg yolk. In addition, enhancing alpha-tocopherol contents of egg yolk by dietary Se supplementation might be involved in antioxidant potential of egg yolk [16]. The protective effect of VE and Se on lipid peroxidation might be as a result of their antioxidant properties in GSH-Px activity. Being involved in the detoxification of pro-oxidants, the reduced form of GSH-Px reduces hydrogen peroxide and lipid hydroperoxide at the level of the cytosol and mitochondrial matrix [43]. In conformity with our information, Mohti-Asli et al. [18] found that the increasing trend of MDA concentration in eggs stored in room temperature and incubator can be mitigated through maternal dietary vitamin E and selenium.
It appeared that the storage time and temperature are the two most crucial factors influencing egg quality during storage. Egg weight loss through evaporation is affected by the relative humidity and temperature during long-term storage conditions. In the present study, regardless of storage temperatures, the egg weight loss was significantly affected at both storage times with more prominence effect seen in treatments with 120 mg of VE (Table 3). Apart from environmental factors, some quality traits including shell porosity and shell thickness involve in egg weight loss [44]. Thus, the probable reason for minimum egg weight loss in birds fed selenium and VE in the current study might be related to their better eggshell quality such as higher shell thickness (Table 3). In agreement with our findings, egg weight reduction was shown to be tempered following dietary supplementation of Se in laying hens [3].
In the current experiment, albumen height and consequently Haugh unit were significantly improved in VE and Se supplemented groups during storage at 5 °C (Table 3). It seems that maintaining viscosity of albumen is the probable mechanism involved since viscosity and Haugh unit reduction were proposed with the progress in the storage period [16]. On the other hand, yolk pH was significantly lower after 15 or 30 days of storage at 5 °C compared to respective control groups (Table 3). As previously mentioned, lower egg yolk pH in this study may be as a result of higher antioxidant potential and consequently lower oxidative stress in stored eggs.
The antioxidant properties of VE and Se may also have influenced the color intensity of egg yolk. The responsibility of egg yolk color is oxycarotenoid pigments, which are derived from diet. These pigments are lipid soluble and their intestinal absorption associates with the absorption of lipids. When oxidized, oxycarotenoids lose their pigmenting properties. Therefore, the antioxidants present in the body or diet help maintain the stability of oxycarotenoids. In our study, the improvement of yolk color in stored eggs likely result from the antioxidant potential of dietary VE and selenium content.
In our study, dietary addition of VE and Se did not influence blood cholesterol concentration (Figure 2C). Mohiti-Asli et al. [18] also observed no significant effect of VE and Se supplementation on blood cholesterol concentration in laying hens. However, in another study, feeding with VE and Se decreased blood cholesterol concentration in heat-stressed Japanese quails [45]. The concentration of plasma triacylglycerol (Figure 2D) was significantly enhanced only in VE30SP group compared to control treatment and birds fed with other combinations of VE and Se. Thyroid hormone at physiological level is one of most potent agents known to reduce serum LDL concentration. Being involved in hepatic conversation of thyroxine to 3, 3, 5-triiodothyronine, selenium supplementation may lower plasma cholesterol concentration through its key role in thyroid hormone metabolism [46]. TAC of plasma fluctuated and the highest significant figures (p < 0.05) were recorded in birds fed with the combination of VE (30 or 120 mg) and Sel-Plex compared to control group (Figure 2E). Similar with our results, increasing dietary Se levels increased the TAC content of laying hen [46]. Selenium is an indispensable part of glutathione peroxidase enzyme and its combination with VE may protect the body against cellular lipid peroxidation [46,47].
5. Conclusions
In conclusion, Japanese quail dietary supplementation of different VE levels (30 or 120 mg kg−1) and organic or inorganic Se sources enhanced fresh and stored egg quality and the nutritional value of egg in terms of selenium, vitamin E, and egg yolk MDA concentration. By taking all data into consideration, 120 mg kg−1 of VE along with Sel-Plex provide birds with more successful results for assessed parameters. Furthermore, these results provide a commercial benefit during egg shipment and storage by the possibility of improving the maintenance of egg quality, and thereby have important practical significance for human as Se-enriched food.
This article was originally published in Foods 2020, 9, 1324; doi:10.3390/foods9091324. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). 
